Why is your vote constantly switching between me and Flashe, Thomas?

Blacklist: Silver
If she starts posting, then I'll un-blacklist her.

Thomas you are so full of crap. Who pays you to play mafia to allow you to be a professional scum hunter? Also even though you say I'm obv scum I'm not on your list of people you want lynched, not that that's bad for me, but you aren't consistent.

Also I don't like the way people have been saying that the way I'm playing is like last game and therefore I'm mafia. Both these times I have often had other things on my mind so the only reason I am playing the same is because my circumstances have changed, you may have noticed that I also hardly ever post anywhere else on the site anymore. If you want me to change my playstyle and talk like neezles or use incorrect grammar or talk in double entendres then I can if that makes you think any differently of me.

As for Jellsprout, to be honest I think he has the best play in the game so I do find it very hard to consider him mafia and also not to adopt all of his views just because they make the most sense. For that reason I don't tend to talk about him that much, I can never see him as scum, but I also cannot forget that he is a possible candidate for either. Basically Jell is post perfect and I read his posts most carefully of anybodies as he has the most to say generally.

Unvote
Vote:Thomas

Thomas your posts have no evidence in them and I don't see why you can just fabricate evidence against people. Your arguments don't even make sense any more.

Actually that was a list of people I don't want in lylo or mylo.

Well I know your play changes when you're scum because you played well in neopets mafia... not so well in the last game.

I don't get paid to do this. I was screwing around because my reads have been pretty good in other games and I believe in the past I have called myself a professional scum hunter or something. And that's why I suspect jellsprout. What he's doing is making posts that don't reveal much information like you did in the last game. He's then trying to kill off active players at night (I think you admitted you thought I'd be the NK target). I'm not making a case on him though. I never make cases.

You've completely ignored what I've said about how there's probably another doctor. In this setup where there's a serial killer, why would there only be ONE doctor (who is only two shots)?? Was Yuggy a NK target on night 1 and saved by Jorster? I really doubt that. So you explain to me why there was only one kill on night 1. Isa no killing is not an option. He has no reason to do that so long as he is playing to his win condition.

Yeah, I firmly believe there is still someone pro-town aligned with the ability to protect, whether a JOAT or a full doctor. Follow the cop is possible.

So I quickly read over day 2. A few thoughts...

So I can kind of see why some people have Darvince as town. It's like he's so bad that he's town. I'd still policy lynch him but there's worse things going on than his poor play.
Shavey's hammer does not make him scum. I played a game on mafiascum (open 354, Isa) where some guy, as town, accidentally hammered twice in the game. The second accidental hammer was on himself and it was an accident. I know I was clear about L-1 there but shos doesn't even post vote counts often. Shavey is a village idiot.
Harumbai's weird vote count analysis didn't really do much. You need to find scum before those help...

I'd be willing to compromise on lynching Jorster or FlashMarsh. Jorster's dumb voting wasn't only where he copied me on D2 but he also did it here on D1. FlashMarsh does more damage.

Unvote, Vote: FlashMarsh

If you compare Me and Flash, who is acting more pro-town? Its sure as hell not Flash, with his spam posts, and "o guize lets linch joredster" drivel.  

I think she's asked to be replaced, so this is uncalled for.

I have bad eyes, but wow, you must be a bat. So, while I was considering maybe you and soccer are neighbors like we had last game, this seems unlikely now.

Silver did not ask to be replaced. She is just not posting. Also, Thomas and I aren't neighbours.  

I'm pretty sure she didn't.

Ninja'd:
Gawd Damnit Soccer

That was in response to jellsprout saying he was keeping an eye on Harumbai. He never pressured Harumbai though or anything. It's just a load of crap. He let Harumbai off. But I'm not a neighbour with soccerboy. I just have a damn town read on him.

Jorster, when you're ninja'd, you're not required to post what you were going to. You can just leave the page

I figured that it's kind of similar to editing a post if you just leave the page

Oh, and Shavey, how are you feeling about this thread? Want to get Yuggy to get of his inactive behind and start playing the game he signed up for?

Thomas, this is the problem with not making case and not being careful with what you say. Is that what you really meant when you made that post, or were you just vague to give yourself plausible deniability? Are you really not making cases to cause scumslips, or are you just trying to make the weakest townies mess up? Regardless of what the two of you are claiming, I'm convinced you're in a faction together, and it looks like an anti-town faction to me. Why is your cop suggestion bad? Lets say the cop does claim, and has a guilty read. Ok, that means that at best he has one town read too. So, we get only one comftown, and we'd probably lose him that night because the doctor (if we have another) would have to protect the cop. I just don't see that going well, plus it assumes the mafia can't bypass doc protection. It's better for the cop to breadcrum his reads and then if he dies the town can follow him, else he'll have three guilties and town wins.

It's how I play... As town, might I add. The closest I've ever gotten to making a case is probably in mafia 3.5 where I made a case on shos. I've only played as scum once and that was over a year ago and in a small game so I can't really say if making a case would cause scum slips... I don't see how that works. How can a doctor not protect a claimed cop?? Does he have some kind of disability which prevents him from accessing the private message page and sending a night action? What if the cop claims bulletproof cop? Okay it's unlikely but you're kind of pulling crap out of your rear end as well with the doctor protection not "going well" and considering the mafia can bypass doctor protections.

Yeah, yeah that's probably the logical way to use the cop role but do you know what's wrong with this game? Nobody is posting. We can sit here scratching our heads wondering why there's no activity or do something.

I'd definitely say that people have been posting, just not everyone. (yuggy, silver, me)

Thomas, why do you need to add that you're town everywhere?

because he's mafia

Votecount 3.5

Thomas (4) - Jellsprout, FlashMarsh, Snipereborn, Harumbai
Darvince (1) -  Jorster
FlashMarsh (1) - Thomas

Not Voting (5) - Shavey Dave, Silver, Yuggy, Soccerboy, Darvince


With 11 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.
Deadline is the 14th of October, 10:00 AM Interguild time.

o guize lets linch joredster

butt thombpt s betta linch

Considering there was a game on this site which had this mechanic and both of us were in it, I'm calling BS on you.

Then vote him plz

Erm, I already did.
http://www.interguild.org/members/forums/jump.php?to=1349555162
Mod, my vote is one thomas.

...on.

My bad. Vote count corrected.