I would vote you Silver but I'd get yelled at for bandwagoning.

List of suspicions:

Silver (I do intend to vote you one day)



Yuggy (Just a very mild suspicion because you haven't posted much. Is there a reason for this?)

That's it for now really.

Well at the moment I am mostly suspicious of Silver, but I am also suspicious of Shavey.
So my list would be:
Silver
Shavey

I'm not so sure on a third, no-one else stands out as particularly suspicious ATM to me.

What are your thoughts on a Silver lynch?

I would be happy with that, but I don't want to rush it.

I completely agree with that. List of suspicions:

Silver

Yuggy To be honest you seem normal. Your thoughts almost match mine so by calling you scum that would basically make me scum as well.

That is a slightly incriminating statement. I mean, yeah, you'd be a hypocrite. But what if you are both scum?

Hmm, with 11 alive and no dead mafia, that means there are 10 people other than me and each has a 30% chance of being mafia, without considering any game-play...
My thinking is that if anyone crosses the 50% threshold, then they are a good lynch candidate. Then we lynch in order of highest probability. (This is sort of hack math because the increase in "probability" is totally subjective. Still, it's a good place to start.)
I've got my eyes on both Silver and Thomas. A little on soccerboy. I'm weary of jell because.. well he's jell now isn't he? I'm not the quitting type, but 'nuff said.

@Shavey, Yuggy: OK, so I'm on your suspect's list. So, what are your suspicions on me, then?

Also, Thomas, you still haven't posted your Soccerboy theory.

So what if the mafia team is Isa, Jell and Thomas. Maybe Jell suggested it to fool us into thinking it wasn't them...

Interestingly if you look at the first page of Day 1 when Isa was random voted he said that it was time to sell out the other mafia and voted Thomas. That could be more bluffing, but more likely just joking around. Although if you do make a post like that and you are mafia who do you say is a fellow mafia, either you say a townie, but by saying you are in an alliance with them people will think that you wouldn't actually reveal another mafia and count on that person as town. This leaves the possibility of Thomas really being mafia if Isa was. So basically... I got nothing.

Vote Count
- 2.1

Votes:
2 - Silver (Thomas, Harumbai)
1 - Thomas (Silver)
1 - Yuggy (jellsprout)
1 - Shavey Dave (Isa)

6 - Not Voting (soccerboy, Yuggy, Yaya, Shavey Dave, Kooler, snipereborn)

With 11 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.
Deadline for the day phase: January 26, 2012, 11:59PM Interguild Time.

Dando, you forgot my vote on Thomas.

Even she knows how bad your "case" was so the vote was not included in the vote count.

Whoops, fixed. I need to skim through a bit slower, lol.

Oh wow. I know my case is bad but you don't need to shove it in my face like this.


Thanks, Dando!

I am still waiting for your other thoughts, Silver. Harumbai doesn't have much respect compared to Isa so just wait for Isa to vote.

Oh and I see scum in one of Yuggy and Shavey Dave. Maybe both. You are both welcome to come clean as scum right now.

Wow, Harsh.

Oh yeah I can make that less harsh by saying that you are respected way more than me.

Yes, I suppose but it's just straight talking. Getting to the point.

@Thomas. I'm not sure about Yuggy but I don't need to come clean so I won't.

Sorry that sounds wierd. I ment I can't come clean because I have nothing to come clean about.

Kooler has been blacklisted.

Please elaborate on what you mean by "blacklist."

I don't understand this term either.

Are we sure he has actually got his role PM yet or not? Dando can you confirm/uncomfirm this?

He either means that he won't let Kooler in any game he's running in the future, or it may be in one he's playing.