Kooler, you don't post for ages and then you instantly bandwagon everywhere, you always need reasons, just agreeing with the person above is not good enough. First you vote Shavey in your first post, your reason being that he hasn't posted his reasons recently. For a start he has probably been sleeping, and he has posted a lot more than you, and he has shared reasons yesterday for him. You just seen to be trying to cover up the fact that the only reason is because other people have voted Shavey, by giving a bad reason. You haven't properly explained anything you did, only with half thought out reasons and all things of them already said. You then, as soon as Shavey tells you that Silver seems suspicious, vote her with no reasoning. No need to explain is not a reason!
FoS: Kooler
You seem very scummy, but I want to see how you react to Shavey's vote before I vote you.

FoS: Silver
I really don't buy all this busy nonsense, when, as Thomas said, you have time to post in all these other topics.

I'm getting annoyed with Silver, but I think that Kooler is town for now.

I'll put some weight behind my words.
Unvote: Shavey Dave
Vote: Silver

I don't think I need to say this, Silver, but in this game, excuses for not posting content isn't going to cut it. Mafia requires serious devotion.  

FoS: Silver
At my count Silver is now at L-2. I don't want to risk lynching her yet because of a miscount or her having that role that will get you lynched at L-1. But I want you to know that you are currently at the top of my To Lynch List.

You have been avoiding contribution to the game. I don't think you've made a single substantial post this entire game. All you seem to be doing is saying how you obviously aren't Mafia because you were Mafia previous games or how mean Thomas is. Editing your post doesn't help your case any more.

Hmm... I do think my vote is actually better as it was, on Silver. Unvote, Vote: Silver. ATM you are at the very peak of my to lynch list. Kooler, this does not mean I have forgotten you. All you have done is bandwagoning. Luckily for you I do not think your really mafia. I have decided now to place my vote on Silver but -FoS: Kooler- I am keeping both of my eyes on you and using my friend for extra ones. That's four eyes you have on you from me. Contribute to the game do not just bandwagon.

Silver. You have quite a few votes now. I highly suggest that you post.

Shavey... how can you yell at Kooler for bandwagoning and then put Silver at L-1?

that makes no sense whatsoever.

Vote: Shavey

I decided my vote was better on Silver seeing as looking back again on Koolers actions I think he is town. I already had Silver voted in the first place before I voted Silver so I just changed my mind and put Silver back as my vote and just have Kooler FoS'd.

Explain exactly what posts made you think this. Shaveyscum could just be following Isascum so explain this now.

Wait a minute, you had me voted before you voted me then put me back as your vote? 0_0

In all seriousness though, OK so I may have over-exaggerated my "busy schedule" a little. And I guess I paid the price for it. Oh well. That's you get for that, I guess... but I'm wondering if anyone finds Thomas a bit suspicious with all his over-exaggerating as well? Kooler and Shavey are pretty suspicious as well, I'd say Soccer is too a little - HEY THOMAS, where's that "Soccerboy theory" of yours? Are you still pulling a Bmwsu and keeping it a secret?

But I guess my contributions don't matter anymore because I'm gonna get lynched. But I WILL say right now, I'm town. I'm being serious, I'm town, not mafia. Town. I guess I could share my role too, because it's somewhat town-aligned. But I guess none of this matters, seeing as I'm going to be lynched.

Hmm, maybe I should take a break from mafia games and not join the next one while I'm at it...

Vote Count
- 2.2

Votes:

5 - Silver (Thomas, Harumbai, Kooler, Isa, Shavey Dave) [L-1]
2 - Shavey Dave (Yaya, soccerboy)
1 - Thomas (Silver)
1 - Yuggy (jellsprout)

2 - Not Voting (Yuggy, snipereborn)

FoS:

3 - Silver (Kooler, Yuggy, jellsprout)
2 - Kooler (Yuggy, Shavey Dave)
1 - Thomas (Kooler)

With 11 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.
Deadline for the day phase: January 26, 2012, 11:59PM Interguild Time.

Mod: Shavey Dave is not voting for Silver at this time.

Actually nevermind that he actually is.

Okay Silver you can claim. If you are a PR then it's better to have you killed at night than waste another lynch on a pro-town player.

Silver don't just give up now. We don't want to lose a town member just because they can't stick up for themselves. The only reason you are being voted is because you never actually post about who you think is suspicious yourself. All you have to do is call someone else out on why they are more suspicious than you (and trust me there are a few of those) and we will back down about you not playing. I don't really want to see you lynched anyway so Unvote. It really doesn't help that you are so easily intimidated by the votes as this is when you most need to post.

PR? Pro-town? Elaborate please.

Also, my role-


[Ninja'd by Harumbai, I'll reply seperately]

Unvote, Vote: Yuggy

You cannot quote your role PM or any other PM from the mod, no.

Okay so did anybody target you on night 1? You may not want to say what they did in case it was a cop or something.

@Thomas: No-one targeted me on Night 1.


It's kind of hard because everyone seems suspicious for nearly the same reasons and I'm afraid if I post my reasons they'll just look copy-pasted and people will accuse me of bandwagoning D:

But I guess I will post my suspicions anyway...

Kooler - appears to be bandwagoning
Shavey - same as above, also with confusing/weird reasons and/or sentences (see the x3 vote thing above)
Thomas - this is a bit behind now, but appeared to be trying to single me out for not posting when Kooler was just as inactive (and I guess a few others as well?)
Soccer - appears to just be "cruising"

Oh, I should mention those suspicions were a little spur-of-moment. Not all of them though.

Now as for my vote now, I'm thinking Shavey. I'm not sure whether the attempted lynch on Silver was purposeful, but just after Jell posted about how close silver was to a lynch you voted her as well. This is very suspicious as I think that every town member was willing to wait for Silver to post before continuing and your vote made things very risky for the mafia to step in and hammer.

This did not happen however which leaves us 4 possibilities:
1) Silver is Mafia so the Mafia do not want to hammer her.
2) All three mafia were already voting
3) The mafia weren't online in that time
4) The mafia hope that they can convince a town member to do the actual lynch.

And since silver is mafia in only 1 of the 4 options this means there is only 1/4 chance she is mafia (Yes I know that logic is completely wrong...)

Regardless, Shavey's playing in that moment was terrible and it is lucky Silver didn't get lynched.

Vote: Shavey

You were posting in other topics. Kooler wasn't even on.

He did the same thing D1 by almost lynching Jazz. He does it like he wants to end the day before anything revealing comes up (or he's just bad).

Unvote
Vote: Shavey

I think the reasons for this should be obvious. Voting directly after I said how unwise it was wasn't a smart thing to do.

Why Yuggy? It's not that there aren't good reasons it just seems they're less good than the ones for Shavey and the same strength as the ones for Kooler.

I'm back! Okay, I wasn't bandwagoning, I was voting Silver for being scummy, but I will FoS: Shavey for acting strange, not because Jell voted him.

What do you guys think about a soccer, shavey, CSD kooler mafia? Maybe a Thomas instead of a soccer or kooler?

Reasons:
You guys convinced me about shavey. He looks pretty bad right now. Also, since he seems so easy to convince, I'm kinda scared the mafia might try to make a case on me and he'd vote just because three other people did (if he isn't mafia).
Soccer-- Same reasons as D1 + I think he's trying to bus shavey.
Kooler-- Because CSD seemed to be coasting, and kooler looks like he's busing shavey (not sure though).
Thomas-- Because he's been acting a little weird all game. A little too much aggression and too much avoiding giving real answers to questions.

Also in the mix is jell for sort of the opposite reason of thomas. Jell does some stuff, but mostly only when there seems to be some kind of opportunity. I don't think you've really been asked any questions or had suspicions thrown at you before, so I can't say whether you're dodging them or not.
I realize I've cast suspicions on half the players here, but I expect really townies won't take too much offense.

Shavey is now at L-2. Shavey did you even read Jells post? Anyway you accuse Kooler for bandwagoning, and then put Silver at L-1. It makes no sense as you do exactly what you were accusing Kooler for, but worse. So not to put you at L-1, I will FoS: Shavey but that was very scummy IMO.