I'll keep that one for future reference, so that when you want spoilers, I'll quote this, and say AHAHAH

Well thanks for that. =p

Sniper is playing well.

Not really. He's been a scumread of mine since the middle of day 1. =p

but uh. you don't know if he's scum. oh, and there's this other thing.. you're dead

I know.

But if he has been a scumread of mine, he's not doing a good job from my perspective.

Kay night has started, and IU'm having a serious trouble with the Silver slot. what the hell, a nolynch caused by inactivity and PRs not sending their stuff too? :S

When was her last post in the thread? You can do a force-replacement during the night.

Also I predict Harumbai dying tonight.

(btw, way to spoil that Silver is town)

Shavey Dave, Silver, Snipereborn, Yuggy, Flashmarsh, Soccerboy, Jorster, Harumbai, Jellsprout, Thomas, Darvince.

My reads as of now.

you think flashmarsh is scum? interesting. despite his +1 to lynch?

and yes well I had to, I really need help here, nobody seems to be replacing and Silver is important ><

Post publicly instead of PMing people.

And his behavior has been shady, but really, I base that read on mod-meta. I think you might include such a role...but I suppose not? =p

Oh well.

Snipereborn+Jellsprout+Darvince for scumteam 2012!

erm question.

so if they kill thomas, is it legit to give him Silver's slot and not give him access here? XD

lol

No it's not, that's absolutely not kosher, lol. Thomas knows stuff about his own role that the public does not - even if he's a VT - and doing so is far from recommended.

Shavey Dave, Silver, Snipereborn, Yuggy, Flashmarsh, Soccerboy, Jorster, Harumbai, Jellsprout, Thomas, Darvince.

Mod-confirmed in dead-thread through various means

Shavey Dave, Silver, Snipereborn, Yuggy, Flashmarsh, Soccerboy, Jorster, Harumbai, Jellsprout, Thomas, Darvince.

Claim is beyond his ability as scum

Shavey Dave, Silver, Snipereborn, Yuggy, Flashmarsh, Soccerboy, Jorster, Harumbai, Jellsprout, Thomas, Darvince.

Strongest scum play I have ever seen on the Interguild if he is scum.

Shavey Dave, Silver, Snipereborn, Yuggy, Flashmarsh, Soccerboy, Jorster, Harumbai, Jellsprout, Thomas, Darvince.

Implied by the mod in dead-thread, fluff-posts disguised as content

So, this leaves us with the following possible scum teams:

Yuggy+Shavey Dave
Yuggy+Jellsprout
Yuggy+Darvince
Shavey Dave+Jellsprout
Shavey Dave+Darvince
Jellsprout+Darvince

I do not think that Jellsprout and Darvince are Mafia together anymore, now that I look back. Darvince votes Jellsprout too much for that, so we cross that one out.
Yuggy has been on Shavey Dave and ended the day with his vote on him. We're not at a meta-level where people bus early, so I cross them too.

Yuggy+Jellsprout
Yuggy+Darvince
Shavey Dave+Jellsprout
Shavey Dave+Darvince

Here it's tricky. Jellsprout has tunneled extensively on Soccerboy in this game, then switched up to FlashMarsh, but not offering his opinions on other players, making his stance on them difficult to read (which, of course, is pro-Mafia).
Shavey Dave hasn't offered much of reads on people AFAICT?
Darvince has a helpful post here. http://www.interguild.org/members/forums/jump.php?to=1347593831 Shavey is null, Yuggy is very weak town, Sniper is weak town. Doesn't tell me a lot, unfortunately. It makes him slightly more likely to be town for whatever gut reason I can fool myself with...
Yuggy has been...mostly reactive on day 2. He has yelled at Shavey Dave and FlashMarsh, and uh...that's it, I think?

My gut is telling me that the scumteam is:
Snipereborn+Jellsprout+Yuggy

If I'm wrong with just one of those, it's Yuggy. I am convinced in Sniperscum.


(btw - Thomas and shos: this is what a scumslip looks like, that I just found:

Of course, Snipereborn had no posts from day 1 after the claim from Jorster, so this is mostly me suffering from confirmation bias. =p)

I've spoken with Thomas and he told me his role.

GJ balancing, shos...

3p-LyLo, I summon Thomas, FlashMarsh and whoever. Guess who's lynched...?

Clearly Yuggy was likely to die N1, Jorster... >_>

SPLENDID REASONING.

Seriously, Jorster.

Also, Jorster has risen dramatically on my scum-o-meter after learning about Thomas role.

Unless it's actually true that you put two doctors in the game, gave the SK a 50% chance to fail with his shots and called the role "balanced". =p

I fixed jazz not having access to the graveyard. It's case sensitive. Bad Livio. =p

lol

Thomas just wasted his self-power, twas 1shot.

At least he saved himself!!

Not cool regardless to include it.

Jorster is scum with Snipereborn.

why not cool? he was told that he's X-shot about himself, not knowing what X is. he could have been killed by either you or the mafia, or of course, lynched. I think it's wierd that thomas believes Jorster's claim. 2 docs in one game? that breaks setups only one mafia needs to be killed for a stalemate, and if two are killed, town autowin

Yeah, and that's generally not cool, giving players unknown shots - but letting docs protect themselves even once is pretty bad.

And I am also very surprised at Thomas believing Jorster.