why is it bad?

It's not as bad as I might make it sound...but I think it's the mod's duty to be as clear as possible with the players, to avoid unnecessary complications and to make the game not depending on luck or outguessing the mod. That's why I don't like 50% abilities, that's why I think it was pointless to restrict the daytalk for the Mafia, that's why I think you should have simply told Thomas that his self-protection ability was 1-shot.

If you can motivate these things with flavor, then OK, but if you write your own flavor it's usually best to just adjust the flavor to the game rather than the other way around. In fact, that's always the best.

yeah well, the flavor fits perfectly.. meh, I dunno, I wanted to make a confusing game for everybody, that's why I made all the chances(btw, both mafia kills went through! thomas saved himself) and hidden mechanics and stuff...

I don't wanna spoiler it for you by telling

Wat

If you wanted a confusing game for everyone, you should have advertised it as such. At least I expected normalcy.

I meant N1 and N2
-_-;
there's really nothing extraordinary in this game, mostly tits and tats

Oh, lol.

Well, you can't really say that luck didn't play a factor in this game, and really, the less impact luck has on a game, the better, is my opinion.

true.
That was mainly the benefit of town, you see.
the more the game goes on - the more silver's role comes to place. if scum miss and miss and miss, they're practically doomed.

I can reveal the setup to you if you'd like in a pm..

Not in a hurry for the setup reveal, but I am very sure my role was far from balanced. =p

maybe
with you alive, scum and town have equal chances to win I think, and you less obviously, but I'm not sure if the pros of your role would have been enough ><

The pros of not hitting every kill, not having any immunity to cop investigations or mafia kills or any other ability at all until the dices roll my way, which they evidently didn't even if I didn't get killed...in a game with at least one Doc (that also has self-protection, making it risky to shoot him at night as well!), one cop, and la la la. I'm bitter. =p

How many VT's are in this game?

DING DING DING

This doesn't take a genius to figure out, really. It's very typical of Darvince.

Dammit everyone, I want your thoughts on Jellsprout's attack because it is valid!

Jellsprout for town 2012.

Jorster+Snipereborn+??? is the scumteam, but it pains a little to drop Jellsprout from the equation. Sorry Jell.

"I don't have a satisfactory answer to X, but here's some deflection, what's your reply to Y?"

Scum 101. Thomas has Snipereborn as his strongest town read, or at least had during Night 2...I'm wondering if he'll see this.

And really, the amount of people taking the selfvote (and IMMEDIATE unvote - it's done the same minute, no posts in between!) of Darvince seriously is frightening.

Isaaaaaaa replace me as a mod again, I'm V/LA till monday.

OK. I suppose that's quite some time, and a lynch can occur, so give me the whole setup in a spoiler.

well what you need is this:

CURSE YOU!

Well...I'm not too mad.

But seriously, my reads were 100% perfect during day 1. I nailed the complete scumteam, and only swapped out 1111Jorster1111 for 1111Darvince1111  because he claimed 2-shot Doc. I'm sad that I wasn't town and lived this game...Curse you Thomas for not protecting me!

Btw, general tips to Jorster - when attacking someone with the intention of voting, if you know that you're going to end up switching your vote, START with doing the vote-switching. When you do it like in your attack vs. FlashMarsh, it very much looks like an after-construction. This goes for all alignments.

LOL

DUDE.

"OK, I am completely lost. I have no idea who I think is scummy. Hey, you over there, do my work for me, and please choose a townie that's scummy and not an actual scum!"

NEVER let others do the analysis for you. It's bad town at best and scum at worst.

LOL

and yeah, I have NO FREKIN IDEA *curses* how jorster hasn't been lynched yet.

WHAT
HOW THE HELL
did you get to the scum QT?

lol. I sent a PM to the youngest of the group.

But, yeah. I'm surprised that Jorster is holding his own still. We'll see what happens - there's a lot of momentum against him right now, but no votes.

I do have to say that Jorster has improved significantly with time. His play isn't perfect, but it's certainly better than in previous games, even previous days in this game.

Also, I have to commend Soccerboy for playing a great game so far in terms of reads and overall pressure. This is by far his best show so far.

Edit on October 10: Mostly everything from this point and onward assumes that you've looked at the spoiler to find out the setup! Beware!