Wonderfully? He has correct reads, but he can't make a case to save his life, and at least three townies think he's scum - Harumbai, FlashMarsh, Shavey Dave. Being part of town is not about having correct reads and then cursing your allies after you're dead, it's about lynching scum, and Thomas isn't doing that.  

With three votes on Jell, I think you should extend. If you'd like, I could do votecounts and such.  

Don't extend.

Town's dead. GG.

Yup. Harumbai probably won't change his mind regarding his reads, and they're ALL wrong - believing the Jorster claim, having Jellsprout as town, not saying anything but passively including Snipereborn into the town category...this means that it's essentially 4 votes against a scum lynch, so everyone else must agree to a lynch for it to happen, including those not active (Yuggy).

R.I.P. town. You probably didn't deserve better.

Maybe if one of the inactives was scum....

lol let's just tell who the mafia is and see how well the town cooperates!

lol. It'll make for better discussion than laughing at least.

Stubborn: Yes.
Arrogant: Well, yeah, mostly. Does not a scum make, though.
Not needed: Easy now.

Not discussing ideas: False. He does not go very in-depth unless asked to repeatedly, which is a problem, but he has certainly shared his thoughts and ideas.
Ignoring what others say: If you mean your Mason theory, well, Harumbai, it's because you're flat out wrong in that one.  

Anyway, happy new night.

D2: No Lynch
D3: No Lynch
D4: No Lynch

Shos, consider calling the game over at this point...

I should try this defense in a court.

"So you say that I killed this man? WELL WHAT DID HITLER DO?"

actually there's a slight chance for town. I can modkill the inactive brothers, in the morning, regardless of the night actions by everyone. if scum manage to kill someone, that would lead fo a 7p lylo, or 8p mylo if they don't/they kill one of the inactives.

I'm aware of the fact that midkilling them is pro-town(one might say) but, it's kinda like my game with bmw - kooler being not there literally almost destroyed town.

In fact I think I will do that.

Darvince just posted.
Harumbai, thomas, yaya and flashmarsh are active.

I'd like to hear your opinions tho, before I modkill them and show their flips.

Even though it is a very drastic measure, I am not entirely opposed. I support it, and if you get flak for it I'll defend it.

Send a PM to Shavey Dave though, because he posted during the day (it was pretty contentless though).

Krap, lol. mafia's rolls are so lucky in random.org; not even once, in all their kills, in three rolls, have they failed.

1/3 is fail, with best of three rolls(it's same odds, trust me). they got 2,2,2 -_- this means yaya is dead; the cop - which has investigated three times in this game, and all three dittos... -_- I wanted him to live!!

oh well. flips, modkills, and scene will be revealed when I get home.

Chance mechanic is incredibly stupid. I much prefer mafia succeeding every time than the opposite. >_>

I gave Yaya access here.

well they did scucceed every time, so there, BE HAPPY.

yaya if you're here tell me if you wish to recieve ANOTHER "you failed to bla bla" message... >_>

Well, happy perfect accuracy, Silver/Yaya. =p

two games in a row for yaya...

GOD*************DAMMIT!
I have a feeling we're screwed now. I haven't read through all of this topic, but I'll make a prediction now in case you guys have deduced the scum through logic earlier in this topic.

Jellsprout
Snipereborn
Jorster

I knew SOMETHING was up when Jell/Sniper stopped disagreeing for once and decided to go after somebody who didn't even matter. Flashmarsh was being to dense to realize it. I think Harumbai may have/will catch on.

Do I still get the results of my night action, Shos? Just curious. I'm hoping they didn't janitor me so people might see that I was the detective and realize I kinda knew what I was talking about. But since Yuggy/Shavey are getting janitored, it's pretty much as over as possible without being over. I will read through the topic now, and probably post another response later.

eh sure, you didn't manage to get a result, AGAIN, lol.

Lack of shots at town might have been your bane, lol. the dittos are cop immune, so eventaully it was planned that your slot would figure out that anyone who they don't get a result of is scum. you just picked SCUM SCUM SCUM 100% correctly, lol.

I had a feeling that those results meant something different. A "your investigation was unsuccessful" would've sufficed if that was the truth. And since the result for Jorster was worded exactly the same as Jellsprout's, I was suspicious. I can understand making one ditto investigation-immune, but all three is pretty much the same as not being immune, with the exception of a rare roleblock. Kinda pointless, IMO.

If I survived the night regardless of my result on Snipereborn, I certainly would've claimed and said that Jorster and Jell came back mafia. Nothing like a semi-true cop claim to make the ignorant townies shut up.

*punches wall for putting Jellsprout at L-1 only to unvote him literally 1 post later.* I have to be more confident in my suspicions or else I'll never accomplish anything. I mean, not like Thomas headstrong, but one post from someone I put a L-1 that didn't honestly say much shouldn't convince me to drop the case immediately.

Still reading topic... almost done.

well I'd expect that you'd think about massclaiming, and when there's no blocking role, you'd have understood

I had the same scumteam as you, only several days earlier

Enjoy my furious complaints when reading through. =p

Monday, October 22 2012, 3:02 pm EST

Current Interguild Time:
Mon Oct 22 2012 6:07 pm

GG guys.