I heard a gunshot in the distance, then a sort of metal sound, almost as if the bullet ricocheted off it, but when I looked outside, no-one was there. Later that night, I looked outside and saw a dead woman, holding a mirror and wearing a full set of armour.

Shavey Dave was Reflector, Town Aligned.

-----------------------------------------------------------

This day ends on the October 18th.

With 8 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.

List of Players

1. Thomas
2. Silver
3. Yaya
4. Yuggy
5. CSD
6. Soccerboy
7. KoolerTheFirst
8. Typho56
9. shos
10. Jell
11. Nebnebben
12. ShaveyDave

I don't really have any ideas on Shavey. Once it was established with evidence that he was a reflector, that made him the obvious choice of who the mafia would kill overnight IMO. I'll post more when more people post more.

Nooo Shavey...
Random hint: those walls to that manor look impenatrable
Help me decode this guys.

In no way do I endorse this statement as true, but it's probably saying that somebody with a highly regarded character/important role is immune to something? I know that's general, but I really doubt anyone got "the wall" as a role.

Probably immune to night kills. Role that comes into my mind to do with a manor, is probably the mayor, but I think soccerboy said he can only vote two people as his role.

That'd be overpowered if the mayor was NK-immune, cuz then if he made a convincing roleclaim, nobody would bother trying to vote for him during the day for fear of accusations. Like I said, don't take my ideas too strongly.

if i couldn't be killed at night we'd win no prob xD

Silver, I said yesterday you weren't off the hook, and I would like some contribution from you.

CSD it's very unlikely silenced two nights in a row

Stupid not editable posts...

What I was saying is CSD, I would like you to contribute more today as well, as it's unlikely your silenced again.

The problem is that I don't have much to say at this moment, there's not much going on in the game right now.

(I'm being serious here, if you don't believe me then I would've said something earlier.)

Vote: CSD

I am not buying the "silenced" thing at all. If you are silenced, you usually get three posts per day. Yet yesterday you only made one. You didn't make full use of this post either. You just accused two people, but didn't fully analyze their posts to show exactly why they were Mafia. The silenced excuse doesn't explain why you were so silent the first day either. You couldn't have been silenced then.
My guess? You are Mafia and afraid to slip up. You know that no matter how hard you try, you will always act different when you are Mafia than when you are Town. So you are posting as little as possible, because the less you post, the less mistakes you can make.

I am also guessing that the Mafia killed Shos and targeted someone immune to Night Kills tonight, and that the SK killed Thomas and Shavey. From the Mafia's perspective it makes little sense to kill Thomas and Shavey. They were both high targets for the lynches, so the Mafia would have benefited more if they were kept alive.

Could it have anything to do with a mayor as rich people live in manors for example mayors?
Also does anyone think soccerboy is suspicious? I want to know because you can never be sure if someone is completely town and I'm pretty new to mafia games and would like to hear other people's opinions on my opinion (if that makes sense) soccerboy, I think you are really townie so don't take this as an attack please.

I disagree with you here. I think the mafia killed Shavey overnight, because most of us believed his RC and it'd look bad to support a lynch for the supposed reflector. I think they also killed him so he'd be one of those kills that offered little information cuz we already knew who he was and such.

I think it's a coin toss as to who killed who on the 1st night. There's not really of way of telling IMO, since nobody knew anybody else's roles yet. Both Shos and Thomas were mediocrely regarded players, so it would've even looked acceptable if a townie accidently killed them, let alone a Mafioso or a SK.

FoS: CSD
I'll see if he actually posts today (as in this 24 hour period of time). Jell's right in the fact that he still could've posted more (unless guyguy changed the rules on silencing for this game?), and he wouldn't be silienced twice in a row most likely (I doubt most silencer roles even let people do it in consecutive days/more than once). And if he is truly innocent, there should be no problem with him posting on here. (He and Nebnebben are the only ones  who have posted yet "today"

PS: Typho, you should consider getting a avatar. I almost always scroll past your posts while reading a thread cuz there's no image to jut out the length of them, lol. Just a thought.

Well guys this is my predictions atm

MAFIA:
Silver
CSD
Nebneb

Town:
Yuggy
Yaya
soccerboy
Jell/Typho

Independent:
Jell/Typho

Out of jell, Typho, Silver, CSD and Nebneb, one is town, one is independent and three are mafia. I think our mafia team is CSD, Silver and Nebneb, but I'm not sure out of jell or Typho who is our SK.
FoS Silver
FoS CSD
FoS Nebneb
FoS Jell
FoS Typho
This is assuming me, Yaya and soccerboy are all town.

Suddenly I saw somebody take out a gun and shoot the Church Minister straight through the head.

Typho56 has daykilled Silver.

Silver was a Beloved-Godfather Investigator, Mafia Aligned.

Well Yug, Silver was mafia and you are wrong about Yaya: he is the serial killer, I investigated him and found out he was the SK and that either Silver or soccerboy were mafia; I guessed and now Silver is dead. Except for the bit about me and jell being the SK, I agree with you on the roles now. This is why I'm doing this:

Vote: Yaya

We really can't have two killers still on the loose tonight.

I am terribly confused about what just happened. I think Typho has a Jack-Of-All-Trade role except he can use his kill during the day.
There is no reason for him to kill a fellow Mafia member and if Yaya turns out to be the SK, then I suppose Typho must be Town and should be trusted.

I am fairly certain Yuggy and Soccerboy are Town. So with Silver as Mafia and Yaya as SK this leaves CSD and Nebnebben as Mafia.
Let's take out the SK first.

Unvote: CSD
Vote: Yaya

Yup. I could kill once in the day and you're right about my role too, also I am absolutely certain soccerboy is Town and I am also pretty sure about Yuggy and Jell so:

FoS: Nebnebben
FoS: CSD

(Sorry about this double post...)

I've just understood the hint: In this game Yaya, Silver, Soccerboy and I live and work in a manor (I forgot the name) so I think only someone who lives in the manor can kill someone in the manor at night and so if we get rid of Yaya now neither me nor soccerboy can be killed in the night. Also I could only use my day kill on Yaya, Silver or Soccerboy, also proving this. I now believe Soccerboy is a Townie Mayor as in Day 1 he had two votes.

Vote/FoS Count

CSD (3 FoS, Yaya, Yuggy, Typho)
Jellsprout (1 FoS, Yuggy)
Silver (1 FoS, Yuggy)
Typho (1 FoS, Yuggy)
Nebnebben (2 FoS, Yuggy, Typho)
Yaya (2 Votes, Typho, Jellprout)

This day ends on the October 18th.

With 7 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.

------------------------------------------------------------------

Updated List of Players

1. Thomas
2. Silver
3. Yaya
4. Yuggy
5. CSD
6. Soccerboy
7. KoolerTheFirst
8. Typho56
9. shos
10. Jell
11. Nebnebben
12. ShaveyDave

Damn, I can't double vote. CSD or Yaya. I'll go with Yaya for the moment as Typhos argument is convincing and he has a lot of evidence to back him up.

I TOLD you Silver was mafia. That leaves CSD and Nebneb.

Ok so if Yaya dies you AND soccerboy are safe? That would be nice...

So, Yaya's evil? Now this point in the game has really confused me. Your logic does make sense, and I agree that we can't have two kills tonight so:
Vote Yaya

This must be the weirdest, most game changing day ever...

Oh, lets clean up:
UnFoS Typho
UnFoS Jell

You do know you didn't vote at all? 0_o

I think that's what the hint means but I can't really be sure... I guess we'll just have to wait till tonight (in the game obviously)!

Oh sorry,

Vote: Yaya

By the way, why do you think I'm mafia Yuggy. It owuld be nice to have some evidence to beef up that accusation.