so who did you investigate night 1? what do you know?

Isa is town.

I got Isa as Mafia, so maybe I am a flawed detective.

I didn't think you did too bad. For the record, you are not a flawed detective (I would have revealed that in your death scene). I guess Isa is doing something right, lol.

It was too hard to go right against him and remain undiscovered and even though I tried to be sort of subtle, but let people know if they went looking through a few hints incase I died. I think he noticed...

damn, isa plays good as mafia then. I was sure that he was town. he plays exactly the same he played in my game where he was town

It's pretty exciting being dead and seeing what people are saying in the mafia forum, but they're all wrong. The reason I knew Thomas wasn't mafia was because Isascum clearly wanted him dead. I actually investigated Jell N2 so everyone is assuming who I will investigate/did investigate wrong. I hope they find Isa before it is too late, I left a couple of hints, but they're unlikely to see them especially if Jell isn't even listening to what I said yesterday about Thomas being town.

IMO if you're the detective and you get somebody as mafia, unless you can get them lynched without it, you should probably just claim. Breadcrumming is more likely to result in your death than the mafia's. You're lucky they couldn't janitor you.

Sorry for flaking on this game, btw.

What happened with you?

really what happened.?

anyway harumbai, since Isa is a very experienced player considering this game's players, I'd claim immidiately and have him lynched; this game has so many power roles, there must be one that can protect you. it's sort of like a gambit on follow the cop, but the chances are very good.

Lol I was mafia in a game once where we didn't successfully night kill until night 5. Really weird game.

Yeah, I wasn't sure how to proceed, but realise now that I got it wrong. I could either make sure Isa was lynched or not do anything suspicious and try and find another mafia without getting lynched. I wasn't sure whether anyone would believe me if I said I was the cop though...

they'd believe it. why would mafia risk getting killed so early in the game?

can anyone link me to thomas' claim? I probably missed it and don't wanna reread.

GODDAMMIIIIIIIIIIIIITTTTT SILVER STOP BEING ONLINE WITHOUT POSTINGGGG

hopefully she reads the dead topic later. this is goddamn annoying, she's online for 54 minutes and doesn't post there..

She doesn't have much to say even when she does post though...

that's terribad =\

and...now she quits. last site-wide mafia game, I think. oh well =\

So I reckon Snipereborn might be mafia with Isa and possibly Yaya. Isa keeps running things and if I was alive and not the cop I think I would be able to see the flaws in "If thomas is still alive tomorrow we lynch him". Snipe's ability could be a very useful mafia ability and Isa set it up so that he is cleared town by negating Yaya today so he could well be mafia. Any thoughts among the dead?

... ...

Welcome, Shavey and Thomas!

Lol good effort Shavey, good effort. Did Mozart actually suggest something along those lines? I vaguely recall something like that having been suggested before. If anybody has a link to that post I'd like to read it.

Harumbai you did well but when you get a guilty, you MUST out yourself; especially in this PR only setup. I am the real doctor and my role won't be revealed until D4 starts but I could have protected you and we could do follow the cop. I do think you are MVP and you were so pro-town that I protected you on N1. So I guess it's a Yaya, Isa and jellsprout scum team? Yaya isn't even pro-town in this game. Nobody was actually except for you. On N2 I did protect jellsprout but I also said I may change the action later on during the night. I never got around to re-reading and doing that. I was actually considering protecting you on N1 but 1) Protection failed on N1 2) I gave you slight scum points for thinking I was town way too well. This would have worked out really well if you had claimed cop on D2. Anyway, on N2 I was poisoned and told that I would die at the end of D3. I asked the mod if my death was announced at the end of D3 or on D4 and it was D4. I thought the indie poisoned me so I wanted to attract attention and get targeted for the kill by scum so there could be one less kill on N3. I don't know if scum actually did kill me though. If they didn't and they try to kill me (or even janitor me), my full role is revealed on D4.

Here is my updated blacklist just for your information.
- Kooler
- Jazz
- Silver

Wow Harumbai, you could have at least been extremely aggressive towards Isa. It's more likely that he picked up on your town read on me than your (accusations?) against him. You could have pressed him to reply to your scum team guesses as well. After that maybe he would have given away a partner or two from other guesses or something and then you claim. You don't necessarily have to do it at the start of the day. Did you ever consider it and when?

So today was mylo? And the only way the town survives the night is if the mafia tries to kill you?

He said at one point that his "role only allows him to be suspicious of Isa" or something. It took me a couple tries to spot it.

Nice pointless list.