i just realised if it's MYLO then not voting would be a much better idea.

Mainly because I wanted to hear what you guys had to say first, in case there is any reason for why no one else seems suspicious of Teo, because I think it's weird that I'm the only one who seems to think Teo is scum.

That said, I also tend to be very cautious with my votes, as you've probably made note of in the other 2 games I've played in. However, since the deadline is fast approaching, I will cast my vote before I go to bed tonight. But before then there's no need for me to place my vote right now. (or at least I don't think that there is)

This is exactly what I'm talking about when I say bad play. In general, yes, voting during the early portion of the day should be discouraged in case the mafia get bold and double hammer, but we're past that stage. We're at the part where we're trying to figure out who to lynch. Not lynching anyone is a terrible idea. A no lynch followed by a mafia night kill means 4 people left tomorrow, 2 of them are mafia, town can't successfully lynch anymore since they don't have the majority.

I'm not convinced for Teo and I'm still looking at soccerboy. But then Teo is voting soccerboy so I dunno. But I read back and thing "soccerboy is such scum," but then Teo's slot has absolutely no content.

Let's make this clear right now: if he lynch town and lose this game right now then this game was kind of a joke anyway with nobody filling atvelonis' slot and Isa not posting for a long time.

I would have liked to have heard soccerboy's opinion before I went to bed, but I guess we just can't have nice things.

I can see how soccer is suspicious, specifically his fluff posting from day 1 made me very suspicious of him towards the end of D1, but I still think Teo is the better option to lynch. Though his arguments have been flawed, he still has made an attempt to scumhunt on both days. Teo however, in his limited posts, voted for soccerboy for reasons that do not make any sense at all (noticing the 30 minutes between Teo confirming/Day 1 starting, and posting suspicions == mafia???), expressed that he had nothing to add about day 1 because he was a non participant, and then when I tried to push him to actually give thoughts on day 1 because that was a terrible excuse, he ceased posting even though he was still active on the interguild at that time.

Regardless of how poorly, everyone except for Teo has contributed to the game. Even if you have been lurking, Yimmy, at least you've bothered to post here when addressed. The same cannot be said for Teo.

Oh, one thing I forgot is that Teo actually completely ignored me requesting he give his thoughts on day 1, not once, but twice:
Teo wasn't responding to me when he said that he didn't have anything to add about day 1, he was responding to Thomas.

As I said before, what comes to mind here for me is Harumbai, after the 2nd mafia game I played in (I think), complaining about how hard it is to scumhunt when you're the mafia because you already know who the bad guys are. Teo's problems sound very much like this to me.

Right now I think either Teo-Yimmy or Teo-Thomas (you're the best remaining player, but I'm still not convinced of your innocence). I feel like Teo-soccerboy would be a longshot unless soccerboy made a post in the mafia topic suggesting his partner create some distance between him by voting for him or something like that, but I don't think so. What this does remind me of is the end of the first mafia game I played, where in my mind, I narrowed it down to Thomas-Jell or DBX-Jell as the remaining mafia, and instead of pushing for a jellsprout lynch, I basically let everyone else decide between Thomas and DBX. I don't plan on making that mistake again.

Vote: Teo

Vote count:

Soccerboy (1) - Teo
Teo (1) - Quirvy

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch

Day 2 will end on Monday, July 29, around 6:50PM Interguild time

teo... i will vote at 6:00. if your role happens to be something... else, i may wait till 6:10

i'm going out to eat and probably won't be home by 6:50 so
[b][b][b][b][b]vote: teo[/b][/b][/b][/b][/b]

The deadline is fast approaching. If you're going to do something, Thomas, now's the time to do it

Oh yeah.

Vote: Teo

Good game?

It's not over til its over. No matter how this turns out, I still think Teo was the right choice.

But I would hardly call this a good game. Nice to see Teo and soccer decide to not show up at all for final 24 before the deadline.

So you're still town aligned, Quirvy?

Of course.

Anyways, Jorster's not here, but simultaneously we've reached a lynch and day 2 has ended, so we probably should stop talking here. Just because you seem to think we've lost doesn't mean that this game is over yet.

Generally speaking you're allowed to speak until the mod closes the topic. Just saying...

Locked!
A lynch has been reached!

In a lot of pain right now, so no flavor for you, just be aware that Teo was:






Roles being released now

I can't believe Teo was town!

Here's my reasoning for Thomas+Teo as the scumteam:



If the scumteam is Yimmy+Thomas I'll be a not too happy camper.

Because you were mafia, right, Thomas?

Haven't read that but I was the cop.

what.

All my reads were COMPLETELY off.

Well, hats off to Soccerboy for playing a great game as scum?

Roles:
1. Thomas - Cop
2. Soccerboy - Mafia Goon
3. Atvelonis - JOAT
4. Isa - Vanilla Townie
5. Quirvy - Mafia Roleblocker
6. Flashmarsh - Vanilla townie
7. yimmy7 - Vanilla Townie

(Roles were assigned randomly using random.org)

Role PMs:


Sorry to say, Isa was wrong on all counts.

He didn't play great. I wanted to lynch him.

Reveal the Mafia topic?

Did you investigate me N1?



Did Teo even send in an action N1, Jorster?

The two people you had as Town were scum... This rarely happens

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/NkmiM2HNTMK