here are the individual results:
Isa
Pride and Peril :: 7
Unwanted Presence :: 4
Math Proportions :: 8
Brain Killer :: 6
lc :: 2
Surrender :: 1
Eternal Energy 1 :: 5
Just a Cave :: 9
Apocalypse :: 3

yaya
Pride and Peril :: 7
Unwanted Presence :: 5
Math Proportions :: 3
Brain Killer :: 2
lc :: 8
Surrender :: 1
Eternal Energy 1 :: 4
Just a Cave :: 9
Apocalypse :: 6

neofriendly
Pride and Peril :: 2
Unwanted Presence :: 6
Math Proportions :: 4
Brain Killer :: 7
lc :: 8
Surrender :: 1
Eternal Energy 1 :: 3
Just a Cave :: 9
Apocalypse :: 5

Seems like Harumbai is the new Ckjr when it comes to winning comps...

Harumbai have 1st place forever... but I???????????? 2ND PLACE???????????

Heres my specific results. Make sure I calculated everything right.
#1ride and Peril
Difficulty:2.5/3
Fun:2.75/4
Design:1.75/3 Too many spikes and a bit empty on the right.
Total:7/10
#2:Unwanted Presence
Difficulty:2.25/3 Could probably beat if I knew what to do.
Design:1.25/3 A bit blocky but good traps.
Fun:2.25/4 Fun for only a bit.
Total:5.75/10
#3:Math Proportions
Difficulty:2/3
Design:1.75/3
Fun:2.5/4
Total:6.25/10
#4:Brain Killer
Difficulty:1.5/3
Design:1/3
Fun:2.5/4
Total:5/10
#5:lc
Difficulty:1.75/3 Could complete it if it wasn't as boring.
Design:1/3 Traps are either to easy or to hard and gem and heart could be better than a area that you just explode and watch.
Fun:0.5/4 All is to easy except the middle on the right, which is way to hard.
Total:2.85/10
#6:Surrender
Difficulty:2.5/3 Got stuck not to far (Upper-right)
Deisgn:2.75/3 Traps were good and only a bit of empty space.
Fun:3/4 Pretty fun!
Total:8.25/10
#7:Eternal Energy 1
Difficulty:2.35/3
Design:2/3 Some good, some blocks of terrain, some empty rooms, most good.
Fun:2.5/4
Total:6.85/10
#8:Just a Cave
Difficulty:0/10 Beat on my first try.
Design:0.2/10 Least it isn't cheatable!
Fun:0/10
Total:0.2/10 But it goes under all 16:9 caves for not being 16:9
#9:Apocalypse
Difficulty:2/3
Design:1/3
Fun:3/4
Total:6/10
1:Surrender
2ride and Peril
3:Eternal Energy 1
4:Math Proportions
5:Apocalypse
6:Unwanted Presence
7:Brain Killer
8:lc
9:Just a Cave

Gee, looks like we all had different opinions, here was my view.

Surrender: Amazing speed cave, totally deserved 1st.
Eternal Energy: It's not that it was a bad cave, it was a good cave, except there were caves gooder then it.
Apocalypse: To much timing involved for me.
Unwanted Presence: I was hoping I'd even break 6th for this cave, is was one of my less likable caves.
Math Proportions: Nice puzzle cave.
Brain Killer: I really liked this cave, I was like "Where the hell is the door" when I got to the end of the puzzle.
Pride And Peril: I hated this cave, if Neezle's cave followed the rules this would of deserved last.
Ic: Hmm, this is akward Me/Neofriendly gave it 8th while Isa gave it 2nd. Tbh, I have no idea what Isa saw in this cave. Both of the arrow traps at the top required no skill and the platform speed-trap could be cheated if you got moderatly lucky.
Just A Cave: learn to follw the rules Neezle. Hatpc-Fail

Yay! I got 3rd! That was the first time I ever got 3rd...

Yeah, Cedric, you really improved in this comp.  You totally deserved third place.

Surrender was the best cave in this comp hands down. I got to the final trap of the cave but died there, and managed to have fun the whole time.
lc - Well...I actually beat the cave! That counts for something to me. And I had a lot of fun. However, it was way too small to come close to first place.
Apocalypse would have been placed in second place if it didn't feature a trap you had to complete while being invulnerable. The rest of it, as far as I got, that is, was lots of fun.
Unwanted Presence could have been so much better if you removed the treasure chests hidden behind the original secret areas. I tried to tell you, Yaya, that they don't enhance the cave in any way, at least not for me. Otherwise, the cave was quite good, but to me it felt a bit like Surrender, only slightly worse at most things. Still, it was good enough for fourth place.
Eternal Energy was quite fun, but the use of a quite difficult "invulnerable trap" ruined this cave for me. If you would have removed it you might have placed in third or something like that, Teo.
Brain Killer never really cut it for me. I never found it that fun, and because the cave started off at once I didn't have the time to figure out exactly where to go, what to do and so on. I don't like most non-stop caves.
Pride and Peril wasn't that good either. It lacked in most departments and I never played it long enough to get to enjoy it.
Math Proportions got me really frustrated. I had no idea what to do and I didn't get any far. I really disliked it. Sorry, Fractal/Ckjr.  

reply to yaya

it's called LC not IC.

lc means ladder chambers.

  

Hmm, always thought that was a I. Oh well, the title sounds a lot worse then the abbreviation.

Two things.
The first trap of EE1 isn't that hard. Also, I cheated BrainKiller.