Fair enough, Jellsprout.

I don't understand why people call me out on "normal" behavior. I have played two (2) games on the Interguild. One of them was almost two years ago, and I was scum in the other. If you think my "normal" behavior is seeming like town when I am scum, well, uh...


Why did you sidestep the issue of Shavey Daves actions? I asked you why you thought his defense of you was poor yet he was a null read, you have yet to reply to that.

Buboy, Conzy
1. Thoughts on my claim on page 1.
2. Thoughts on the votes on Shavey Dave.
3. Thoughts on Thomas.

Unvote: Conzy
Vote: Thomas

The vote on Conzy wasn't doing anything and was mostly an instinctive reaction, so...

And I encourage people to step up their attacks on Shavey Dave, or vote someone else.

Official Vote Count

Shavey Dave (4) - Rocketguy, Snipereborn, Yuggy,  Conzy
Conzy (1) - Jorster
Soccerboy (1) - Jellsprout
Isa (1) - Thomas
Thomas (1) - Isa
~~~~~

Not voting: Soccerboy, Darvince, Shavey Dave, Jazz, Buboy.

With 13 alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.


Modnotes:

I have not said this in the rules, so I add this now:
Do not use any of the censors to hide anything in your posts. No small text, no hide, no grey color, etc.


Yuggy is V/LA until Sunday.

UnFos: Shavet

Not must else.

Unvote

Conzy is at PaX for most of the day today, but I'll harass him through text to come on. I'll be at PaX for the next three days, so I can go on only after 8ish, my time.

Because I feel your accusation of him is wrong.

  Seems to me, that Thomas has a role that has to do with Shavey, such as the neighbor role Shavey and The Yugmeister had last game.

Like what Isa said, he's "sidestepping" the Shavey issue.

@darvince
Hmm, I thought you had been in more games. And I could swear that jorster has only been in one. Am I in an alternate universe or something?
And, yes, the reasoning on jazz was a joke, as evidenced by my reasoning being "jazz".

The shavey wagon is clearly dead, but the only real options atm are isa and thomas. Thomas feels vaguely scummy, but thomas always feels vaguely scummy to me. It's difficult to ask him about anything because isa's already asked him about pretty much everything under the sun.
Isa's claim makes me believe he's town, but isa being town doesn't make thomas scum. The problem we have right now is that there aren't any arguments with strength. We have 5 new(ish) players (darvy, conzy, rocket, jorster, buboy), one currently absent player (yuggy), and jazz. The rest of us seem to be just carpet bombing each other.
For now, I'm just going to Unvote.
Of my null reads, jellsprout seems to be the same as ever and soccer is being more active than normal, which is a good thing. Last game, soccer was crazy inactive and he was scum. So for now, I'm getting an ever-so-slight town read on him.
NINJA'D by jor yug jor

Allow me to take a step back then.

V/LA from now to Sunday.
Gonna be visiting my family and I won't bring my computer.

The hunt for mafia isn't greatly helped by the fact that we haven't really seen anything from rocketguy and Conzy. Darvince hasn't really posted anything worthwhile. Jorster hasn't done too much and Jazz seems too have slipped under the radar. I also believe that half of my votes are from people who have simply voted me and done nothing (well maybe one other post) else. All I can say right now is that some people need to post. This:



is a good example of a bad post. Conzy this is all you've done and rocket guy I think you've made two posts. Will check. Rant over.

Also Soccerboy's inactiveness last game was because he was in Europe. He's still town to me though.

Shavey ninja'd me.

Could be this again that you're getting at.

Rocket guy: 3 posts one saying 'face palm' to a post and one stating a random vote though. The other one was voting me without any reasoning just 'definitely acting suspicious'

Conzy: 1 post voting me saying 'has been acting suspicious lately.

WOW.

Oh, Buboy hasn't done much either.

Also to clarify I am not away away, and won't be too inactive at all. I just will be on less at certain times, and have bursts once or twice a day.

Same follows for me.

IMO, Conzy would be a fine Lynch. He's posted once, in the past 8 pages, had no original ideas, and just doesn't come on.

This is true. His one terrible post has done absolutely nothing. Please get him to come on Jorster. Rocketguy is another newbie who has not helped in anyway. How are we meant to know what side they are on if they have done next to nothing?

I would do a list but certain people haven't really done anything. I'll give you a brief indication on a few of the more active players.

Thomas - Slight SCUM. Inactivity and difference in play style.

Isa - Slight TOWN Scumhunting.

Yuggy - Slight TOWN ^^

Sniper - Null Not sure about Sniper. will wait and see...

Soccer - Null ^^

Has Thomas' play style changed? And why does the inactivity necessarily make him scummy? Also if you do think Thomas has had a change in play style, why do you not mention that Isa is a little more aggressive this game? (Why is it ignored in that case, but not for Thomas)

He's at PaX right now, with me. I'll spam-text him when were done.

Const is, I mean.

.

The inactivity seems scummy because it has never happened before. To be honest I haven't really noticed Isa being more aggressive and can't really remember what he played like last time. Both things which make Thomas seem scummy to me are not massive things which is why I said slight scum.

ATM, Yuggy I'm very sketchy on everyone. I've got a slight scum read on Thomas and a slight town read on you and Isa but other then that... I don't know.

Not sure about the UK, but most people already have or are starting school in the next few days. I think that Thomas' inactivity is unusual, but not scummy.

/prod buboy, rocketguy, conzy, jazz

However we can't get 4 replacements so....
Either of these four I'm fine with lynching. There's no way we can tell whether or not one is mafia.
Would the random approach work? I understand that it's not common, but it might help out with later days. If all four of them are here with only 11 players:

Assuming 1 of those 4 is mafia... 3 town inactive + 3 mafia = 6 players who most likely won't vote for a mafia member and 5 who are willing to vote. However, we would need 6 to win.

Kill one of them, if the kill is mafia, great! If they flip town (again assuming at least one is mafia), that'll be 2 inactive, 3 mafia, where the town will have to advantage of 6 people who will vote against a mafia member without hesitation.

Rolled 60 dice with an average amount of 3.3833333.
So #3 of that list... would be Conzy.

Vote: Conzy

School for me starts on Tuesday and I know I know it starts on Wednesday for Yuggy. I think Conzy woul be the best to lynch has he has only made one terrible post. I'd be happy to lynch him.




So would Jorster. Anyone else have any thoughts about Conzy?