Best of luck!

Why am I always the evil guy? Maybe it's cos I like to kill off guys in my comic. Meh, I'm not really complaining.

LET'S SMASH SOME CRATES!! ...at night.

All of the Protagonists now have read their PM's, so I suggest that you share the information that you've received. Especially Jellsprout has probably a lot to tell.

I thought I was good, how wrong I was! I'm Hannah

Good job on surviving your first day, protagonists.

Now, night actions. What do you want to do?

MUST KILL JAZZ MUST KILL JAZZ MUST KILL JAZZ

I mean, he's pretty much just being inactive. He doesn't post much and he's inactive 3/4 of the time just so he won't be lynched.
(Also, if someone kills me my dying wish is that you destroy Thomas.)

I agree that Jazz must die and I already have a later plan on how to kill Thomas. Whahahaha. I've got roleblock and detective, who should I use them on. (I've got two of each per game)

I think I might go 'detective' on soccerboy, as he's not likely to do anything else.

I'm noting that you want to kill Jazz, but I can't help but think that Jellsprout wants to have a say about that. However, I don't think he has anything to say about you investigating Soccerboy, neb.

Here is how often everyone posted, not counting double posts:

Thomas - 11
Quirvy - 7
DBX - 6
Yaya - 6
Nebnebben - 6
Jellsprout - 6
Jazz - 5
Silver - 4
Guyguy - 3
Soccerboy - 3
CSD - 2
Harumbai - 1
Bmwsu - 1

So you see, Jazz has actually posted more than you, Silver, and almost as much as Nebnebben and me. It is true that all his posts were neutral, he didn't direct any accusations at anyone, but this only makes him harmless. He is unlikely to start a vote.

I'd like to keep Quirvy and CSD alive for now. The point of playing this game is to have fun, and without them I suspect the fun will drop pretty fast. However, they are a leader figure. If they start a vote, I can assure you that person is going to get lynched. So we should be wary of them. That is why I suggest we investigate them, starting with CSD. If his role is too dangerous, such as Detective, we will kill him anyway the next night.

Who I propose we kill tonight is Yaya. He is active and has made some solid accusations, none directed at any of us. He said he suspected me of being in the mafia, but that unlike his other two accusations this was decided randomly. We can easily kill him without any of us becoming suspicious.

Why I don't propse we kill the inactive members is because they will be lynched anyway. If Harumbai, Soccerboy and Guyguy keep their low postcounts, they will probably be lynched the following days. It is also unlikely for them start any vote rallies, so there doesn't appear to be any harm in keeping them around.
Furthermore, none of them have voiced a suspicion to either of you. The most likely people in the game for people to investigate are Quirvy, CSD and me. If they investigate CSD or Quirvy, it won't matter to us. If they investigate me, they'll see that I'm "Canadianstickdeath - CRATE aligned". So we won't have to worry about them using their powers against us either.

So in short, I propose we kill Yaya and investigate CSD.

I'd also like to say that you two are playing perfectly. Your post counts is about average, you don't try to actively avoid attention by making blank posts and you don't try to visibly protect each other. Keep it up!

I'd also like to add a reminder to you, Nebnebben can roleblock and investigate during the same night if you want to.

Jell, is your proposal of killing Yaya and investigating CSD definitive or just a suggestion for now?

Just a suggestion for now. I want input from Silver and Nebnebben before finalizing anything.

Edit: I'll bold my final decisions.

Can the Godfather be killed in the night? I might investigate CSD and roleblock Guguyxtreme.

I've tried to avoid using terms like that, but a case of bad copying and pasting resulted in references to the Godfather being left in the text. Ignore that - Jellsprout may be killed during the night, there's nothing in his role PM saying that he can. However, Silver cannot be killed during the night, which was mentioned in her role PM.

I agree in that we should investigate CSD, but I would like to roleblock Guguyxtreme, because I've got a bad feeling....
Also our biggest threat is going to be a serial killer, so finding and killing that serial killer should be our top priority. But in killing Yaya, I think killing Quirvy would be better, because then we could blame it on Thomas, and 'honour' Quirvys words of if 'I die in the night, lynch Thomas.' Also do serial killers show up when you investigate them?

Unless I've stated otherwise in my role PM (or if a character has an uninformed ability), all abilities will show up upon death.

I also hope that you don't have any outer contact with Guyguy regarding this game. If I found out you've been sharing information, I'll have to disqualify you both.

Is there any reason you want to roleblock Guyguyxtreme? You only get two roleblocks during the entire game and it is a bit of a waste to use it on the first night when we don't know any roles yet and on a person who has so far only showed hostility against Quirvy.

Thomas isn't a threat. People still detest him, so I doubt anyone will follow him if he starts a vote rally. He will get lynched at some time. Neither him nor Quirvy appear to target any of us, so I don't think we should fear their night actions yet either.

O.K, lets go with your idea, then. Do I send a PM now or do you do it?

I have to post it here, but I'll wait one more day to give Silver a chance to give her inputs.

Neb, there's no need to send a PM to me, I wrote your role PM in a poor way. You use this topic to tell me your night actions, there's no need to send a PM to me.

You make some good points Jell, I guess I'll kill Yaya if that's what we all agree on?

I'll make it official then.

Night 1 Protagonist actions
Jellsprout - kills Yaya
Nebnebben - investigates Canadianstickdeath, refrains from roleblocking
Silver - refrains from killing

I'll refrain from janitoring anyone tonight, but it would be a good idea to try that tomorrow.

I have some good news and some bad news. Your killing of Yaya was successful, details will be posted during the start of day 2. However, in a tragic turn of events, Nebnebben was killed during his investigation of CSD, and he won't be around to tell you the results of his investigation.  

Well, this sucks. Sounds like either CSD has a role that kills when targeted or there is an Elite Bodyguard with a slightly altered description to protect against anything rather than just night kills.

Let me rephrase myself - everything you know is that Nebnebben is dead and won't share his results with you, but his investigation was successful.