Day 1:

Day 2:
(Harumbai only posted after I told him too.)



Harumbai, you aren't the one to say this because you aren't posting much. I think the mafia may be putting suspicions on other mafia like what Silver did last game here.





Day 3:
None yet.

I was hoping for a little bit better, but it's still something. (and a bit defensive, perhaps)

Perhaps I won't forget this when considering you from now on, but it wasn't that impressive.

You seem to have either missed this post, or just neglected to also quote it:



From the very start I passed it off as a joke, poking fun at CSD feeling so strongly about who votes in what place. Theoretically I could have known ahead of time that guyguy wasn't independent, and planned to vote third to make myself look guilty, making myself look more innocent, but what fun would this game be if you never had to defend yourself?



Anyways, back to the earlier parts of your post:

Am I supposed to be shocked by this?No, which is why I'm so suspicious. Even fellow townmembers are bound to say stuff that you're going to disagree with, like how I disagreed with CSD's attempt to get jellsprout lynched (because it would never work this early on, you have to go for the other mafia) and like how CSD disagrees with me on the topic of whether or not we should consider nebneb's list to hold any meaning. (Although that's assuming we're both town) Of everything you've said the only thing I can remember disagreeing with was your claim that CSD might have been the independent that killed nebneb.

I think you're partially right, Harumbai. I think the reason why I'm suspicious of you is that your arguments have as little flaws (if not less) than CSD, me and Jell's, yet you don't try to do anything with those arguments. It's like you're a mix between a follower and a leader; you come to the same conclusions that a leader does, but you've never actually done anything particularly remarkable with those conclusions.

CSD has:
Accidentally led the BMWSU lynch
Tried to lead a lynch on Jell
Was the first to vote for guyguy

BTW in case you didn't know I'm pretty sure that the reason he chose guyguy wasn't because he was in the middle of jell's list (4 people, there is no middle) but because he voted right after jell and he might have reasoned that if guyguy was mafia, he'd get enough on jell to lynch him.

Jell has:
Almost lead a successful lynch on DBX (fell apart 2 votes short)

I have:
Tried to get everyone to not talk about the independent publically
Tried to break up the CSD/DBX vs Jell voting (I couldn't tell you if it was me, or DBX and CSD that ultimately led to it being broke up)
Sort of led the guyguy lynch (I was the one with the big post of offenses)

You haven't really done much with in the big picture, which may be because you prefer not to, or may be because you just don't have as much time to do it, but someone whose posts make as much sense as your, who's not doing anything remarkable with their ideas, that makes me suspicious I guess.

Or as you like to put it you don't jump to conclusions, and why is that? You don't want to look suspicious? I've jumped to conclusions before, and I've only ever had to defend myself once, from the accusations of a mafia (nebneb) and an independent(guyguy), about my joke accusation on Thomas. And even with all of the mistakes I've made that could make me look suspicious, and there have been a decent amount that I could list out for you, nobody has really come after me.

And the idea that you shouldn't come to conclusions to avoid suspicion is ridiculous. If you don't come to conclusions, how are you going to go after the mafia? Not coming to conclusions and not taking action is something that the mafia is going to do because they don't want people to be suspicious of them, so yes I can be suspicious of you and rightfully so if you take that stance.


Also don't assume that because I'm focusing on a few people, I'm not looking at anyone else for it. Among the you and Jazz combination, I also consider these following pairs:

Thomas and Jellsprout
CSD and DBX
Jell and Jazz
Jazz and Silver
Jell and Harumbai

And as more and more posts get made I'm sure that the list of pairs will change. Focusing =/= Only paying attention to one thing.




Anyways moving onto that head hunt thing, what you said is pretty silly for several reasons:
1. The closest I've come to leading a head hunt was when I posted those reasons for why guyguy looks like mafia. Although had we lynched someone else and guyguy killed someone overnight I'd have been leading a headhunt on Thomas who I still can't believe isn't independent.
2. If you're talking about Thomas jumping on my bandwagon and FoSing you, he's thomas and everything he does should be disregarded because he's Thomas.

I wanted to start the head hunt on guyguy but I didn't think I could manage to get everyone to stop voting for jell and DBX and start voting for guyguy all in one post. I wanted guyguy dead because I'd been really suspicious of him from the start of day 2, but I would have been happy to settle for anyone else like jazz or silver (wouldn't have wanted them to choose soccerboy or thomas, though, because I thought those were town and indie), but I was very happy when he chose guyguy because I had more dirt on him than anyone else.