So anyone else wanna throw out any thoughts or anything?

I have my list planned out like this:
Town:
Soccer
Jell
Quirv
Silver
Harumbai

Mafia:
CSD?

I'm gonna use this as my list, and I'm gonna FoS: CSD only because of CSD supporting Death the other day. Yeah, it's pretty weak reasoning.

I'm suspicious for supporting the only person I know is town besides myself. That's nice.

Hey, wait a second! From CSD's perspective, it wouldn't be nice if he was suspicious because he was supporting someone who he publicly acknowledged to know to be town. In fact, it wouldn't ever be nice to be suspicious!

I think CSD may be attempting to deceive us here.

I see a lot of fishy things here.

My first assumption would be either CSD's role is linked to mine OR he's a mafia detective under a fake role. But since the mafia's detective is already dead, the second arguement is flawed. So, for now, I'll assume he's town. But don't cross your fingers.

Thomas's posts are very sparse and threadbare. It might be from a silencer, but his posts don't look very condensed. And all he bases his FoS's on are # of posts, which is never a good reason to lynch. As his posts have been very lacking themselves, it's pretty hypocritical to blame on lack of posts when yours are so bare. And, he's annoying.

FoS: Thomas

Quirvy just makes a lot of assuptions. Plus, I'm not going to read through them all. From my skimming though, I see a lot of (semi-) legible evidence. A lot of people should follow this (cough*thomas*cough). Bare bones are not going to help us through this game.

Harumbai just said I didn't post enough. Well, here you go! He suspects Quirvy, which is pretty understandable due to his massive posts. But activity is good, so I sorta, but don't sorta, see the problem, you know?

Oh Jell, how I suspect you so. I'm not even going to repeat my (weak) reasons.

FoS: Jellsprout

Hmm, I just noticed that CSD could be town. Only if he was a Jack of all Trades.

My apologies for not posting recently but I have now read all posts I missed while I was on vacation.

Harumbai your FoS on Quirvy is weak because I think it's obvious Quirvy is just trying to annoy CSD there. If Quirvy was mafia he would be pulling a big one on the town and with all the posts he made so far I'm sure he would have screwed something up by now. You are in a far more suspicious position at the moment because you were not on nebnebben's suspicious persons list. Right when I saw nebnebben was mafia I, knowing I was town, immediately trusted those on that list more (maybe not Silver) so your suspicions are weak.

Silver is near the top of my suspicious persons list because of her posts. In almost all her posts I remember she has some strange excuse like she said many times something like "I haven't been posting much guys!" then in her most recent post she said her mom was bugging her to get off the computer. She's 'flying under the radar'. I am voting for either you or Jazz today unless something big comes up. Here's the FoS:

FoS: Silver

Jazz your post on day 2 where you said you didn't want to risk lynching a town person was suspicious. Quirvy already explained that if town never lynched in the game they won't get far at all. Your posts don't have much information in them and in my opinion you are one of the main mafia suspects at this time.

I doubt nebnebben would go a night without investigating somebody so if he investigated DeathBunni X on that night but got killed would the other mafia receive the results from the investigation? Isa can you tell us this? If not then CSD may actually be a town but I'm still suspicious of him because he's smarter than all of us combined.

I am not silenced, it is more the opposite actually. I do not base my FoS's on the number of posts a user has posted. I am also taking nebnebben's suspicion list into account when I FoS people. On day 1 I wasn't sure if Quirvy was town, independent, or mafia but now I'm almost 100% sure he's town because of this list. You are far more suspicious than me because you aren't on that list. If I was mafia I wouldn't start the day with all these FoS's because that's going to attract attention to me.

What have you done that looks suspicious? You want to lynch me for not much reasoning. You better give up because you have been trying since day 1 and you have got almost no support for that. On day 2 you made some long post but then Quirvy pwned you and you almost got lynched (I sort of wish you did.) Today you defended the mafia and tried to talking about how the kills on night 1 worked. It's pretty obvious now though because we know the independent was a serial killer. Perhaps you want to stall our time?

So today I'm voting for Silver, Jazz, or maybe DeathBunni X.

Quirvy, did you think I was independent since day 1? I thought you said you thought I was town before this day started?

Okay, I think that Jazz could be mafia, he gave a list of people he thinks are town, but with no reasoning. These are also quite a few people who have been accused recently, as if he may be trying to strike up support for himself. Then he accuses CSD with little thought behind the reasoning and then says that maybe he was wrong a bit later. I think that the lack of explanation behind accusing could be a sign that he's mafia because of how hard it is to make up convincing fake mafia claims. Also it doesn't pay to push too hard in any one direction incase of starting a mislynch so that could be the unconvincing CSD argument.

In view of that
Vote: Jazz

You're not the brightest crayon in the box, are you? Read this:

Something else to contribute before I go... I can't really think of anything, but just a couple of FoS. I can't explain them now, but I will explain them later, and I will go read those other posts.

FoS: Thomas (I think this is kind of obvious actually) and FoS: Jazz

@Silver

I read the first 5 words of that spoiler then I gave up. It looks like that posting streak where you talk about not posting enough hasn't ended yet.

Thomas, if I was mafia I wouldn't want attention. I would fly under the radar instead of making me FoS's.

And these votes for Jazz are verrrrrrry suspicious. It's been so soon and you vote? I'm thinking it's mafia! And that Jazz has an important role.

How would the Mafia know what Jazz's role is?

One-use detective thing? I don't know, what powers would Armin have?

A big, logic filled post by Thomas? That seems too good to be true!

So naturally it might be.

Thomas, you admittidly contradict yourself by saying that you trust everybody on that list, because they were on the list and supposedly nebneb wouldn't put mafia on that list because he wants to take attention away from them, but you're suspicious of Silver who is also on that list. If you trust everyone else on the list because of the previously mentioned reasoning, but you're suspicious of Silver and think she may be mafia then that argument doesn't work because nebneb in that case would have put mafia on that list. Either everyone on that list is town, or you don't know who anyone on that list is from the list. You can't say, "Well, because of that list, everyone on the list except Silver must be town"

Which is exactly why you would

No you don't. Even if she turned out to be mafia you'd have been lynched today for my suspicions that you were independent.

???

As previously stated, in response to DBX's arguments, mafia doesn't want to stall us they want us to lynch as fast as possible or mislead us during the day.

Day 1 I wasn't sure, during night 1 I thought you might have been mafia, during day 2 I was pretty much sure you were independent, and now I'm not really sure.

I never said that you were probably town, I said that you were probably not mafia.



So far the town has done a pretty good job of that.

"I am 12, the holidays" Yeah I dunno if I can do this either.(sarcasm)

Here we go again...

She makes a very good point, you, Thomas, defend yourself because no mafia would ever draw as much attention to themselves as you have, yet you still chase after DBX who'd drawn attention to herself with her jell vote and long argument.

Also Harumbai is making that vote in the same manner that CSD has been, and he's doing it because part of the reason I(I guess thomas too, but he doesn't count)'m suspicious of him is because he doesn't take enough action.

Anyways, if you're suspicious of Harumbai we might as well throw CSD out there, too, because he's made even more early votes!

Vote/FoS count:

Votes:
2 - Jazz (canadianstickdeath, Harumbai)

FoS'es:
2 - canadianstickdeath (Thomas, Jazz)
2 - Jazz (Thomas, Silver)
2 - Thomas (DeathBunni X, Silver)
1 - DeathBunni X (Thomas)
1 - Harumbai (Thomas)
1 - jellsprout (DeathBunni X)
1 - Quirvy (Harumbai)
1 - Silver (Thomas)

With 8 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.
Deadline for the day phase: June 7th, 2011, 11:59PM Interguild Time

I'll be gone during Thursday morning to Sunday evening, so don't expect me to post updates during that time, and if someone should be lynched, please refrain from posting anything in this thread. I welcome everyone to manage this Vote/FoS list while I am gone.

There's no such thing as an early vote, only an early lynch.

I'd think that voting early in the day would count as an early vote.

Early vote leads to early lynch so CSD is wrong.

Not to rush you guys or anything but no one posted anything yesterday.

I'd love to help spur you guys on but since I've last posted no one has said anything other than CSD claiming that there's no such thing as an early vote, and jell and thomas both correctly disputing that claim.

...

...

...

And geez, my arguments fail at arguing.

If we aren't getting anywhere right now either start discussion or end the day early. Quirvy how about you do something to spark activity?

How about instead of me, Jazz gets this day active again with some quality posts. It's clear that people want him to prove himself because he hasn't said anything, so this might be a good time for him to get his thoughts out there in well structured arguments.

Unless of course he wants to get lynched, because that appears to be the direction he's heading in right now.

Or we could just lynch jazz if he doesn't comply

I'm all for that Quirvy and it looks like we won't get any further today so I will:

Vote: Jazz

If Jazz is town I am getting more suspicious of CSD.