Had you thought through your reasons at all prior to posting? What Thomas said in his reply wasn't really anything special.

Tell me some of your reads that you are sure on. Top 3 scum reads, top 3 town reads?

Top Scum Reads:
Thomas - Overall Aggressiveness
Jazz - Just like what Sniper said, All trolly when Town, Inactive when Scum
Not really sure about 3rd person here. Maybe Jellsprout?

Top town:
Isa - Pretty sure it's obvious
Sniper - Useful scumhunting
Shavey - Provides Excellent reasoning.

Well I thought I explained it already but I'll keep it simple this time. Aggressive =/= Scum

I realize that, but you have never been as aggressive as you are now in any games I've seen.

Shavey is seriously third on your list? For 'excellent reasoning'? WTF?

??? No way. You're pulling BS out of your rear end again.

Why is that a problem? I'm just saying he is really good at explaining himself when he does something.

That was to Flash.

What are you talking about? You have been Hyper aggressive this whole game.

Darvince, I see you're online. What's your take on this?

jorster i'm writing another long-ish post

Good.

He's always aggressive in mafia games, unless I'm missing something.

large-sized post is coming in about 1 hour from me (comparing previous games to this one)

@Isa (even though you're speaking to jorster):
scumreads
jazz (inactivity la extreme)
FlashMarsh (really ******* aggressive to hellsprout and only hell)
Jorster reasons here new reasons: loads of small posts, but no large posts with reasonings and such, only defending

townreads
soccer
isa
sniper
other town:
harumbai

null
shavey: not really active, not good reasoning, but no scumslip stuff, usually has bad play
silver: never really comes on too much
yuggy: getting inactive but posted well at the start
hellsprout: both scum and town points
thombot: really aggressive but that's kinda null

Hmm? Thomas is aggressive to everyone, not just one person. Hell isn't really doing anything horrible, but he's not doing anything great yet. I agree with you on Jazz, but that's only the last two games. He's super inactive, but he was trolling in G4 so that he could get out of the game.
Shavey being really good at explaining things? wtf?

All of his Votes so far have been filled with Evidence, unless I'm missing something.

So then if one who is anti-town aligned fills their posts with this "evidence" you are talking about then they are town aligned??

COME ON.

"He gives reasons when he votes" is a horribly bad reason to call someone town. I am pretty confident I did that in my last game as scum, that didn't make me town.

Wow, nice new post from Darvince. Could you at leat try to bring new ideas into the game. Please? Also, I'm not going to defend myself against your scum read because, yes, I am aggressive, but that's because I'm confident. I'm leaning towards a 75% Darvince 25% Jorster scum now.

Ok, I still Have a Town read on him. He hasn't made any slips, or any super bad posts,

Ninja'd
Darvince would be a fine lynch by me.

Well everyone can have excellent reasoning compared to this... I mean "Pretty sure it's obvious" What kind of an explanation is that?

Also I have yet to see Thomas being overly aggressive this game. If people are not aggressive it appears that things do not happen... Can you link me to a post in particular?
Most other people also have reasons for things you just may have top look up a previous post because they aren't going to post their arguments again. If you're not prepared to go back and reread peoples arguments from previous pages you are going to miss a lot of information.

And yes, Isa I would agree that you did a good job of looking town when mafia, that is the job of mafia, to explain themselves as a townie would.

Wait, you think he is mafia or you are just trying to rally support against anyone who is not you? You made no mention of him before...

The point isn't that not posting reasoning attached to your votes is scummy (or towny), rather, that it's not a town-tell to have reasoning attached, like Jorster argues. Do you agree?

I think that not having any reasoning for your actions is scummy... I think I agree with you though, I'm saying that by the "Town-tell" scenario then we get out almost everyone as town which can't be true.

Shavey has made no bad posts except for like all of page 4.
Darvince is town, and WHY is darvince a good lynch? Because you need to kill of others?


And sorry for the inactivity in this past little bit. My power went out unexpectedly and it took a little while to get the internet back up and running.

Harumbai, are you planning on voting to lynch anybody in the future? Same goes for snipereborn (unless he voted since the last VC).

I'm not planning it, but I'm not against it. I think I'm worried about how the votes are flopping all over the place. There seem to a few people willing to lynch almost anyone as long as it saves themselves. I guess Jazz is a fairly safe vote for now and if he would care to come and explain his absence then I can change it. Otherwise Jorster is looking like a possible vote too.

Vote: Jazz

So after everyone was saying jorster-shavey scumteam... you post this.
So if I thought that shavey's reasoning wasn't good... and I thought that shavey looked scummy, does this mean that you are now worse than him?

I still don't get the Thomas overall aggressiveness thing ._.
Jazz is always like this. i'd rather attempt to find a replacement.

So jorster - shavey - sniper?
That seems possible. I don't see why jorster puts sniper above all other people. Sniper's been really inactive this game. Yet jorster called thomas inactive -.-

his only semi legitimate scum read is jazz, but wait! That was copied off of sniper...