I know that feeling. Rest in peace, original iteration of the June 16th weekly update...

Ahhhh... that must've been bad. Thing is this is th first time in thi game that I've actually done a big post like this and I go ahead and loose it all.

Attempt2

@shosh I think a scummy townie is fair. The scummy side is just me sucking at mafia. So...

Shavey Dave - ^^ Scummy townie.

Yuggy - Barely contributed and lied about big posts. When is later? Scum

Quirvy - I'm not really sure about him but have nothing against him. Town.

Thomas - ^^ This is how he normally play right? Town.

Jellsprout - again nothing really against him so I'll call him town. Town.

Yaya - The town did not need any mor information about my role yet you tried to get it. Hmmmm. Scum.

Jorster - Your role could be real - it probably is - but you have contributed much and I'm still not entirely convinced by your role. Town/Scum.

shos - A PR's chance of getting killed has increased because you lied about your role to protect yourself. Scummy eh? Scum

Soccerboy13452 - At first I was convinced you were town but now I'm not sure. The problem is your on a two week holiday with little internet access. Not gonna be the biggest contributed are ya? Town/scum

Oh my god. So many typos. Please forgive me, I'm really tired.

You forgot Harumbai. Can you tell us why that is?

well like me he hasn't gone by the roster, so forgetting one isn't so hard.
anyway, that post still looks bad in my opinion, especially with that appeal to emotion in the next post. but looking at the post you made in Kro's video, I'd slightly think you're town now, since it's not a playing style but more of a recent posting style, or so it seems.

that's bad btw, even outside the mafia, I think, lol.

With website layouts coming back to IC.net and Haily nowhere to be found, I had to do some stuff myself to allow for the layouts to display correctly when Haily brings them back. I've updated the way the site looks! Round five of the IC.net challenge is accepting website layouts as entries so Haily will have until next Saturday to bring them back. If he does not reach that deadline then I guess that sucks because he doesn't want me to do it. Everybody should PM Haily on this site and ask him to bring back the website layouts. I don't care if he doesn't come on here often; next time he comes on he will know he should have done this earlier, lol.

Okay so excuse my rant in the mafia thread but Haily is almost as bad as Livio now, lol.

@jellsprout
You know what I'm talking about. Stop pretending you don't know what I'm talking about. Start scum hunting. I don't know if I'm using WIFOM correctly when I call it out but I don't really care to read that wiki article again. It might help if you give the link.

Harumbai is posting in other threads but not here and his playing is not good enough for me.
Unvote, Vote: Harumbai

Shos is taking the credit for the activity in the game. He didn't mention that this is anti-town activity. He kept posting some stupid "get aboard the bandwagon" image in the thread and now people are talking about that instead of scum hunting.

@shos
What's "the post you made in Kro's video"? It makes you think Shavey Dave is town aligned?

Oops, so I did forget Harumbai. (I didn't on my first list) There was no particular reason I just simply forgot him.

Harumbai - He dosen't stand out a scum but seems somewhat reluctant to share many of his thoughts. I am not aware of his usual play style but he seems hostile and I would like to see him post more. Town/scum

Vote Count 2.10
Soccerboy13542 (2) - Shos, Jorster
Harumbai (2) - Yaya, Thomas
Quirvy (1) - Jellsprout
Shos (1) - Soccerboy13542

Not voting (4) - Harumbai, Quirvy, Shavey Dave, Yuggy

With 10 alive, it's 6 to achieve a lynch.
Deadline is at June 30, 06:00 AM Interguild Standard Time.

point is that when shavey says something, he is wary about it. "That is only my criticism" feels to me like a good explanation for his play here.



I hereby revoke your towniness and VOTE: THOMAS.

that post is so bad and un-thomas-ish. as a start, you give some completely randm paragraph completely unrelated to the game. why would you do that when you have random chat for example? and look at its contents: You bolded

"I have updated the site's look!"
and
"Deadline"
, which is probably hinting to your partner that you posted in your quicktopic and he is not checking it out, and he must do so before deadline. I mean, really, if that is not what you tried to do, why on earth would you bold the word 'deadline'??
superscumslip there.

Shavey Dave
Slightly scummy for self mentioning himself as town twice. Often restates ideas that have been posted before.

Yuggy
Inactive, Only one post today? I can really say anything about it either, but is isn't particularly original.

Shos
There are several things I don't like about his playing style, but most of them are kind of forgivable individually. I don't think I'm going to give him many more chances though before I go with him because these slightly odd behaviours are beginning to add up scum to me.

Quirvy
Has always seemed pretty town orientated. Not many suspicions here.

Yaya
That role claiming incident was pretty bad, but has seemed to redeem himself since then. Having said that I don't think I ever saw a particularly convincing explanation of why he made that/those posts.

Soccerboy13542
His posts are becoming worse due to the lack of time he has to post them, but he doesn't seem all that scummy IMO.

Thomas
Talks often, but doesn't say much. I agree with the town reasoning outlined somewhere that I now can't find though, (found it, page 2).
Wish he would stop changing his avatar.

Jellsprout
I don't really get a town or scum read from him. Similar to how people have problems with me (apparently)

Jorster
Not many meaningful posts, but I generally get a town read from him.
I like his signature.

So in writing this I went through every post in this topic by poster which is why this has taken me over an hour.

Now on to the Ninja'ds


Like I said this took an hour and the posts in the other topics took about 1/2 a minute. You don't own my life and this is a poor reason to vote someone. Also what is wrong with my playing? Not good enough is hardly going to tell me anything, I said I would make this post today and I have 6 minutes left at the moment.
Also the only bit of you post that is actually relevant to the game (I ignored your convo with Jell as that is kind of sub game) is your last 2 paragraphs which are tiny so how can you complain about my posting?


As I have mentioned further up you don't share many of your thoughts either. You see to quite often share other peoples though. I am also annoyed at you telling me that I don't post enough. I'm not saying that I a the most active, but I am by no way near the bottom at least by how I judge activity.

I think I saw a typo somewhere, but then I lost it again. Oh well.

When you put it like that it does sound terrible, but I didn't pick up on that as what he was meaning so maybe it was a coincidence although I agree it was odd for Thomas to write that precursor.

Based on previous post;
Vote: Shavey

Him telling me off reminded me of how little he says and he thinks he can try and accuse me of those things?

Now you are just BSing. I have done nothing post-specific? I have done the most individual analyses of anyone in this game. I have given my in-depth thoughts on every single player in this game several times, I have brought forth several new theories and whenever activity was low I have brought up new subjects to discuss. What have you done? You have done nothing, absolutely nothing to contribute to the game. Pretty much all you've done is lie about your role and post that moronic bandwagon image.

Shos, I have had it. You are harming Town most out of anyone in this thread. You try to downplay discussion and you try to convince to hop on bandwagons without first giving it any thought. You lie about your role and you seemingly intentionally sprout out utter BS about other players to get the mobs focus on them instead of you.
I am through with you.
Unvote
Vote: Shos

I'm sticking with my vote for now. But Shos, you aren't gonna be able to lynch anybody by saying they're generally scummy. You look even worse now by the fact that you voted Thomas, who most already believed was town. I interpreted him bolding "deadline" as sort of a whiny reminder thing that the day ends soon. I don't really get why he posted this 6 days early. But it's not like he'd be reminding his scum partners that the game ends in less than a week either. And last game, Dando made it so scum could only talk during the nights, so there's a chance Isa may have adapted his policy.

I was going to say that the whole IC layout speech was a response to somebody telling him to post something or being called out for inactivity, but I can not find such a post. This just makes Thomas and Shos look bad. You guys really need to start making normal posts, lol. I feel there could be a chance that both of you are town, but you guys are making it really hard to believe. Anyway, I'll wait for both of their responses.

@shos, I jus don't want to come across harsh or unkind and want to get my point across in the nicest way possible.

@Harumbai I thought you might think me 'telling you off' was unreasonable. I said before and you basically reacted the same. I believe the only way to defend your post is to contribute more. I can see why you would get annoyed because as it stands I am in no position to tell you to post more. I do think a vote is too much though. Is that the only reason your voting me or can you think of anything else that you haven't said?

This is where I firstly told Harumbai to contribute more:

http://www.interguild.org/members/forums/jump.php?to=1338649552

His reaction is on the same page.

I think you completely misunderstood me. my point was that I don't have any specific post of yours that makes me think you're scum, and rather, just your general gameplay makes me think that.have I tried to lynch jell or harumbai?

also, in 99% of the games I've seen, scum could only talk during night. it's not a chance, it's usually a high chance; but that post - it is completely irrelevant to the topic, and it makes so much sense for scum to do that.


~~~
I'm not sure what I am being accused of in yaya's post.
about jell's post - if you're looking for 'what have you done?', sepcifically, I can only say that I provoke discussion and well, DERAILED A MISLYNCH ONTO A SCUMLYNCH, but that's stupid and ignorable, so w/e~

what has soccerboy/yuggy/others done?

I didn't really accuse you this time around, Shos. The part of your post that Jell quoted looked like it was lynch justification, I didn't bother to look up the original, so I misinformed myself. And are you still behind the fact that Thomas is telling someone to post in the quick topic, even though you said that mafia can only talk during the nights in 99% of games?

@shos Well Yuggy has done nothing but he has had two school trips. Don't you guys get that? You seem quite harsh on him seeing as it's not entirely his fault. I do think though that maybe he shouldn't have signed up if he had two school trips do wouldn't active. It is slightly annoying that he has done next to nothing though.

Argh. I meant 'so wouldn't be active' not 'do wouldn't active'. Damn you auto - correct and amateur typing skills!

No, that was Thomas, a person who coincidentally you are currently trying to lynch for explaining why he's going to be less active. When Thomas first tried to get that wagon rolling, you instead hogged up all discussion for almost an entire page about a typo Quirvy made. Only when the wagon had gained momentum you started contributing by making such convincing arguments as this:



But please, enlighten me. What is it about my general gameplay that makes me look like scum? Is it the fact that I actually share my thoughts on every person in the game? Is it that I actually support my accusations with reasoning? Is it that I bring forth new theories and topics to discuss? Or is it merely that I revealed to everyone beginning this day just how much of a lying scum you actually are?

@shos
Yeah, I could have also been talking to aliens or maybe I wasn't talking to anyone and just ranting... calm down. I don't know if the mafia even have daytalk in this setup or if they still have a partner.

Anyway I said I could have been talking to aliens to show how bad your accusations are. Can you not resort to this crap?

@Harumbai
You make posts that don't reveal much information.

Jell does have a solid point in that shos was trying to derail the Jazz wagon and shift it to me, but as I recall, shos was actually one of the first people to call for a lynch on Jazz. I think he actually called for it before Thomas.  But if I'm honest, it mostly just seemed like part of a series of shots in the dark he was taking at other people, in an attempt to derail the jorster wagon and move it to someone else. I could of course be wrong, as I didn't bother to check any of this, but I have a pretty good memory.  

Shos made an imaginative vote on three people including Jazz on the page before me. He never really followed up with any suspicions on Jazz though. On page 20 he linked to the last post Jazz made then posted that stupid bandwagon image. But before that it seems like he wanted to lynch Quirvy.