It does raise suspicions though, and they're not in your favor.

I didn't say I wouldn't post or that I would avoid conflict. I said I'm going to reserve my judgement of who I think is Mafia until after I've seen what everybody has to say. You seem to be one of the more suspicious people at this point, but I don't know if that's because you're part of the Mafia or if it's because you've just done more talking than most other people. That's why I'll wait to see.

Point taken, Dando. I misinterpret your post.

FoS: Isa

We can have as many Fos's as we want so why not use em?  

I think most people are restricted to either 8 or 10, depending on whether you count thumbs as fingers or not.

No edit forces double post

I'd defend myself, but you didn't state why you're suspecting me, so I can't do much about it.

Un-FoS:Thomas
FoS: Isa

No reasoning really, Isa just seems suspicious...

Just because I Fos'd you, doesn't make me have an assumption to whether you're Mafia or Town. I just believe you need to be watched closely, for 1. You know a lot about the game. 2. You have been doing a lot of the talking. You may argue that you're just posting a lot cuz you know lots about the game, but I'm just suspecting something deeper going on. Whether you're trying to see who would side in the event of a lynch with you or who is getting jumpy at being accused/accusing.

When we get to the actual voting this will be hilarious.

Again, that's not something I can defend myself against, so I have no comment to that, except for that I know that I'm playing a high-risk game by being active and slightly provocative. I'm not surprised that I've got a lot of votes tallied against me, but I'm not worried.

I did a count of all the votes so far.

FoS:
Isa - 4
Bmwsu - 1
Jellsprout - 1
Silver - 1
Thomas - 1

Now, with that said, I am going to bed. Nighty night, fellow citizens.

---

The ninja filter showed Yaya's post so I am replying to it.

I am not posting a lot because I know a lot about the game - I am posting because I want to make people expose themselves. That can't be done if we're just waiting for things to happen. Throwing around accusations without motivation like Thomas, you, Soccerboy and others may have done recently does nothing to help us figure out who the Mafia is, though, it just shows everyone that you're suspecting this or that person for being a Mafia (which, essentially, is what the FoS does).

There's nothing wrong in being active, on the contrary I encourage everyone to post a lot.

But on the other hand, who do you see as the biggest threat - me, or someone like Thomas or Jorster who hasn't made any kind of impact on the game yet, and maybe won't in the future either? The one you can analyse, or the one that is completely silent? It will be way more dangerous for us to kill of the ones that we can check and analyse on multiple levels, while someone who rarely speaks can only be analysed based on how that person has voted. That is not enough for an accurate vote.

So in order to stir up more activity...

FoS: Thomas

I'm not accusing Jorster yet because he hasn't logged on after the real discussion started.

...which also increases the Thomas FoS count to 2.

I think I'm gonna shut up for a bit and watch these frustrating debates from the sidelines. Feel free to FoS me for not commenting on stuff or something...

Just to stir up activity? I have not said much because I feel it's too early to accuse somebody right off the bat. But I am suspicious of two people now....

Un-FoS- Jorster

Because CSD has confirmed it is all random.

I'll probably abstain from voting the first day.

Technically speaking, you never made a FoS at all, so there's nothing to undo. =p


Indeed you are, but you're not sharing your thoughts on the matter as of why you are suspicious, making you more or less worthless for the rest of us up until that point.

FoS: Silver
FoS: Thomas

One of these two is likely Mafia. Why? Because neither came up with a defence for their FoS. I am especially suspicious of Silver because of FoS'ing someone in self-defence. This could be to avoid a mafia lynch. As for Yaya's FoS on me, is agreeing with soemone not allowed?

FoS: DeathBunni X

DBX is probably pleased that no one is suspicious of her, but that changes now!

Vote Count

FoS:
4 - Isa (Jellsprout, Harumbai, Yaya, Soccerboy13542)
3 - Thomas (Silver, Isa, Guyguyxtreme)
2 - Silver (Thomas, Guyguyxtreme)
1 - Bmwsu (DeathBunni X)
1 - Jellsprout (Silver)
1 - DeathBunni X (Harumbai)

Note, Guyguyxtreme unFoS'd Jorster23, but he never FoS'd him in the first place.

With 13 alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.
Deadline for the day phase: Dec 25, 2010, 11:59PM Interguild Time.

Let's try and keep up activity in this thread. Has anyone else noticed that the starting amount is thirteen- supposedly an 'unlucky' number. Oh, and at the beginning I showed my suspicions against Jorster and SB, I just forgot about the whole FoS thing.

All there is to know about FoS's.



This is true. The best way to avoid suspicions is to make people forget you. Draw as little attention as possible to yourself, and nobody will even consider you when voting.
However, you know this. Yet you still raised the first FoS. You are experienced in this game, yet you still put yourself in the spotlight. Why is this? Could it be, that you planned this all along? You knew that you would be called out on it sooner or later. So you could give your "Accusations raise suspicions, but I already know this, so my accusations would mean that I am not suspicious at all" speech. People would realize how you know too much about this game to make such dumb mistakes, so they won't suspect you at all! You can't outchess me, Isa. I've still got my finger on you.

Wait a second. Everything I've posted applies to me too.
FoS: jellsprout

That quote basically sums it up. I didn't like the fact that we had 6 different posters that wouldn't try to spark the discussion required for a Mafia game, and somebody has to take the first step. I feel experienced enough to do so.

I'd like to phrase it like this: I am experienced in the game, THEREFORE I put myself in the spotlight. I feel confident enough to defend myself while supplying theories about the others, backed up by sound statements. I'm not as sure if everyone else can do that.

Now, being the first one to cast accusations doesn't mean that you're a Mafia, as we've already ruled out. It doesn't mean that you're a villager either, however. In fact, it means nothing about your role. What it does mean is that that person is not afraid to cause controversy and take a slight risk (especially with inexperienced players - no offence to anyone), but that's about it.

I know, I am just trying to keep things interesting. This day will last 8 more days. I can get everybody to hate me now, and everybody will have forgotten about it once the voting actually starts.

Vote: Isa

For everything everyone else said

So, because I am acting suspicious?

I'd also like to point out the difference between a vote and a FoS, in case you made an error.